-
1/21
Ai Feng, 6, parades up and down her block with a United States flag in the Greenwich Village neighborhood of New York Thursday, May 14, 2020, during the coronavirus pandemic. The New York City immortalized in song and scene has been swapped out for the last few months with the virus version. In all the unknowing of what the future holds, thereβs faith in that other quintessential facet of New York City: that the city will adapt. (AP Photo/Mark Lennihan)
-
2/21
Dogs greet each other another nose-to-nose while people gather on a street in the Hell's Kitchen neighborhood of New York, Friday, May 29, 2020, during the coronavirus pandemic. The New York City immortalized in song and scene has been swapped out for the last few months with the virus version. In all the unknowing of what the future holds, thereβs faith in that other quintessential facet of New York City: that the city will adapt. (AP Photo/Mark Lennihan)
-
3/21
Street performer Robert John Burck, known as The Naked Cowboy, poses for photos in New York's Times Square, Thursday, April 9, 2020, during the coronavirus epidemic. He is wearing a mask and his guitar is adorned with stickers that read, "Trump Keep America Great." The New York City immortalized in song and scene has been swapped out for the last few months with the virus version. In all the unknowing of what the future holds, there's faith in that other quintessential facet of New York City: that the city will adapt. (AP Photo/Mark Lennihan)
-
4/21
Protesters kneel in Times Square in New York, Tuesday, June 2, 2020. The New York City immortalized in song and scene has been swapped out for the last few months with the virus version. In all the unknowing of what the future holds, there's faith in that other quintessential facet of New York City: that the city will adapt. (AP Photo/Seth Wenig)
-
5/21
New York's Times Square is quiet on Friday, May 29, 2020. There's a certain kind of silent on the streets of Manhattan. Not the "summertime and the living is easy" vacation lull, or the post-Christmas holidays letdown. It's the only-person-in-the-empty-house kind of quiet now. (AP Photo/Mark Lennihan)
-
-
6/21
New York Stock Exchange employees wait to enter the building as the trading floor partially reopens, Tuesday, May 26, 2020. The New York City immortalized in song and scene has been swapped out for the last few months with the virus version. In all the unknowing of what the future holds, thereβs faith in that other quintessential facet of New York City: that the city will adapt. (AP Photo/Mark Lennihan)
-
7/21
A Wempe store employee places jewellery in a store window, Thursday, June 11, 2020, in New York's Fifth Avenue shopping district. The jeweler is open for in-store and curbside pickup. In the virus times, the near-term and maybe even longer-term impact is undoubtedly going to be ugly. Job losses have been racking up, businesses facing bankruptcy, cultural institutions going under, entire industries like restaurants forced to reconsider everything they do. (AP Photo/Mark Lennihan)
-
8/21
A woman wearing a mask walks by a Louis Vuitton store, Thursday, June 11, 2020, in New York's Fifth Avenue shopping district. The luxury goods store is open for curbside pickup. The New York City immortalized in song and scene has been swapped out for the last few months with the virus version. In all the unknowing of what the future holds, thereβs faith in that other quintessential facet of New York City: that the city will adapt. (AP Photo/Mark Lennihan)
-
9/21
A woman photographs a smashed Chanel store window, Tuesday, June 2, 2020, on Madison Avenue in New York. Protesters broke the window in reaction to the death of George Floyd, a black man who died after being restrained by Minneapolis police officers on May 25. The New York City immortalized in song and scene has been swapped out for the last few months with the virus version. In all the unknowing of what the future holds, thereβs faith in that other quintessential facet of New York City: that the city will adapt. (AP Photo/Mark Lennihan)
-
10/21
Bloomingdale's department store has boarded-up windows, Thursday, June 11, 2020 in New York. The store is open for curbside pickup. In the virus times, the near-term and maybe even longer-term impact is undoubtedly going to be ugly. Job losses have been racking up, businesses facing bankruptcy, cultural institutions going under, entire industries like restaurants forced to reconsider everything they do.(AP Photo/Mark Lennihan)
-
-
11/21
A SoHo street is deserted, Wednesday, June 3, 2020, in New York. There's a certain kind of silent on the streets of Manhattan. Not the "summertime and the living is easy" vacation lull, or the post-Christmas holidays letdown. It's the only-person-in-the-empty-house kind of quiet now. The New York City immortalized in song and scene has been swapped out for the last few months with the virus version. (AP Photo/Mark Lennihan)
-
12/21
San Gennaro restaurant is closed but the tables are set in the Bronx borough of New York on Friday, April 17, 2020, during the coronavirus pandemic. The New York City immortalized in song and scene has been swapped out for the last few months with the virus version. In all the unknowing of what the future holds, there's faith in that other quintessential facet of New York City: that the city will adapt. (AP Photo/Mark Lennihan)
-
13/21
A man walks past an open Kennedy Fried Chicken restaurant in the Queens borough of New York, Thursday night, April 23, 2020, during the coronavirus pandemic. The New York City immortalized in song and scene has been swapped out for the last few months with the virus version. In all the unknowing of what the future holds, there's faith in that other quintessential facet of New York City: that the city will adapt. (AP Photo/Mark Lennihan)
-
14/21
People maintain social distancing while waiting in line to enter a store Thursday, April 16, 2020, in the Harlem neighborhood of New York. The New York City immortalized in song and scene has been swapped out for the last few months with the virus version. In all the unknowing of what the future holds, there's faith in that other quintessential facet of New York City: that the city will adapt. (AP Photo/Mark Lennihan)
-
15/21
Police officers patrol New York's Times Square on foot, Wednesday night, April 29, 2020, during the coronavirus pandemic. The New York City immortalized in song and scene has been swapped out for the last few months with the virus version. In all the unknowing of what the future holds, there's faith in that other quintessential facet of New York City: that the city will adapt. (AP Photo/Mark Lennihan)
-
-
16/21
A man waits for a subway in the Woodside neighborhood in the Queens borough of New York, Thursday night, April 23, 2020, during the coronavirus pandemic. The New York City immortalized in song and scene has been swapped out for the last few months with the virus version. In all the unknowing of what the future holds, there's faith in that other quintessential facet of New York City: that the city will adapt. (AP Photo/Mark Lennihan)
-
17/21
A man walks out of a subway station in the Queens borough of New York, Thursday night, April 23, 2020, during the coronavirus pandemic. The New York City immortalized in song and scene has been swapped out for the last few months with the virus version. In all the unknowing of what the future holds, there's faith in that other quintessential facet of New York City: that the city will adapt. (AP Photo/Mark Lennihan)
-
18/21
A commuters walks on a nearly empty subway platform in New York, Monday, June 8, 2020. The New York City immortalized in song and scene has been swapped out for the last few months with the virus version. In all the unknowing of what the future holds, there's faith in that other quintessential facet of New York City: that the city will adapt. (AP Photo/Seth Wenig)
-
19/21
Women wearing masks talk in New York's Times Square, Thursday, April 9, 2020, during the coronavirus epidemic. The New York City immortalized in song and scene has been swapped out for the last few months with the virus version. In all the unknowing of what the future holds, there's faith in that other quintessential facet of New York City: that the city will adapt. (AP Photo/Mark Lennihan)
-
20/21
Bicyclists and a pedestrian pass through a quiet Manhattan street, Thursday, March 26, 2020, during the coronavirus pandemic in New York. The New York City immortalized in song and scene has been swapped out for the last few months with the virus version. In all the unknowing of what the future holds, there's faith in that other quintessential facet of New York City: that the city will adapt. (AP Photo/Mark Lennihan)
-
-
21/21
Cars head along FDR Drive next to the Manhattan skyline Thursday, March 26, 2020, during the coronavirus outbreak in New York. The New York City immortalized in song and scene has been swapped out for the last few months with the virus version. In all the unknowing of what the future holds, there's faith in that other quintessential facet of New York City: that the city will adapt. (AP Photo/Mark Lennihan)
NEW YORK (AP) β The New-York City that was lingers everywhere in the New York City that is, like flashes of movement out of the corner of your eye.
The subways run, but not all hours, and definitely not with anywhere near as many riders. Your favorite corner deli has your bagel and coffee β as long as you take it to go and wear a mask to get it. Go enjoy the sunshine in a park, but too many other people better not have the same idea.
It begs the question: Who do we become when we canβt be who we were?
New Yorkers, more than in any other place in America, have always accepted as given a cheek-by-jowl existence, treating the streets and subways and parks, their favorite restaurants and bars, the physical geography of the city all as extensions of their own personal space.
βNew York City is a different style of life … of density, of vitality, of 24/7, of no cultural agreement of when we should take a vacation or eat lunch,β says Kenneth T. Jackson, recently retired Columbia University history professor and editor of βThe Encyclopedia of New York City.β
βItβs everybodyβs second home,β he says. βYou can come to New York and find your group. You canβt really say that anywhere else.β
But that was before these last couple of difficult months, when the city immortalized in song and scene as the never-ending hustle and flow of humanity was swapped out for the virus version, of staying near home and social distancing regulations.
The streets have started to wake up in recent weeks. And as recent days of thousands upon thousands of people turning out for anti-police brutality protests have shown, passion for this place, this community, runs deep.
But even that bit of New York spirit carries a risk of an increase in coronavirus cases, as does the mere act of re-opening in itself, as slow a process as that is. The threat of illness and death has abated β for now β thanks to our doing that most un-New York thing of staying away from each other.
The shadow it cast remains, though, as do rules of separation and distance that make the New York City of even three months ago a peripheral vision at best.
In the virus times, the near-term and maybe even longer-term impact is undoubtedly going to be ugly. Job losses have been racking up, businesses facing bankruptcy, cultural institutions going under, entire industries like restaurants forced to reconsider everything they do. Things taken for granted, such as the school day, will look different and be more complicated.
New York City has been shell-shocked before. The raging waters of Superstorm Sandy in 2012 plunged whole neighborhoods into pitch darkness. The attacks of Sept. 11, 2001, covered many in dust clouds.
But βthose were temporary cessations. There was always a knowledge that community could refocus and gather again in some number of days,β said Daniel Gallant, executive director of the Nuyorican Poetβs Cafe, the renowned East Village performance spot.
βEven when we feared for the economy, we also knew that New York was going to find a way geographically, financially and as a community, somehow or other, to bounce back,β he says.
Several hundred thousand have left, The New York Times reported, particularly from the cityβs wealthier neighborhoods.
And a lot of those people likely arenβt coming back, says Jeremiah Moss, the blogger and author of βVanishing New York: How a Great City Lost Its Soul.β
βWhat theyβre discovering as they go back to the suburbs or they go to the country is they really like that kind of lifestyle, they like having a yard, they like having a car, they like having space and thatβs more important to them than whatever they could get in New York,β he says.
But in all the unknowing of what the future holds, thereβs also a thread of hope, and of steadfast faith in that other quintessential facet of New York City: that the city will adapt.
Jackson, the historian, takes the long view. βYou canβt judge the future by the moment. Youβve got to have the perspective of centuries, really,β he says. βThis is not the first time New York has been challenged. It wonβt be the last.β
Some take heart from the recent wave of protests themselves, in which New Yorkers turned out to rallies and marches to call for justice for George Floyd, the black Minnesota man killed by a white police officer, and to call out police abuses in New York City alongside.
The passion on display, the willingness to come together, even in defiance of a city-mandated curfew to get off the streets, was heartening, said Keris LovΓ©, 34, a songwriter and activist living in Bronx.
βWeβre all out there, you know risking our lives because we imagine something better,β she said. With spirit like that, she figured, New York City would be OK.
Caridad De La Luz agreed. Another Bronx native, the poet and activist had been staying in her neighborhood for weeks, refusing to come into her former stomping grounds of Manhattan. She missed it, and worried what the new normal would be.
Then came the protests, and she found a way. She was still leery of the subway, so she drove, then marched, then took a CitiBike to get back to where her car was.
βWe are not afraid anymore,β she said. βWe are taking those precautions, but I donβt have the fear that I had a month ago.β
Gallant and others are also in some ways cautiously hopeful that the disruption of the virus will also strike a blow to the forces of expansion and capitalism that have done much in last two decades to make the city harder to afford, and more generic with the mega-chains and big-name stores crowding out the mom-and-pops, the artists, the up-and-comers.
βWe know that New York City experienced a lot of upheaval in 1970s, there was a lot that went badly at that time, there were economic challenges then. A lot of fantastic powerful amazing artistic and cultural things happened at that time as well,β he says.
Moss echoes that thought. βCities are going to become less popular,β he says, and βif cities are going to become less popular than that means rents are going to come down. And when the rents come down, then cities can become more accessible to a wider range of people and a more diverse landscape.β
And while many may stay away, there will always be those who are drawn here, no matter the condition of the world, to find their own freedom, whatever form that takes in socially distant times.
βWeβll have people who are desperate for cities … because their nervous systems are in tune with the nervous systems of a city,β Moss says.
βNew York will always be a beacon to people who are hungry for what cities have to offer, he says: βCities from the beginning of cities have been places of liberation.β